A PTA Mom Pushed My Daughter Aside at the Halloween Fair to Make Room for Her Own Child, but I Wasn’t Going to Let It Slide

The Back of the Room

The first charge I didn’t understand was $1,140 to a place called Glow Medical Spa.

It was 11:20 on a Tuesday night in early October. I was sitting at my kitchen table in my pajamas with a cup of tea gone cold and a stack of bank statements I had printed at the library that afternoon, because our home printer had been out of ink since August.

The statements belonged to the Westbrook Middle School Parent-Teacher Association.

I had been the PTA treasurer for exactly five weeks.

I read the line again.

09/14 — GLOW MEDICAL SPA — DEBIT CARD PURCHASE — $1,140.00

I went down the page with a yellow highlighter. I’d bought the highlighter for this, though I didn’t really know what “this” was yet. I just had a bad feeling, the way you get a bad feeling when you smell something burning and can’t find the stove that’s on.

Starlight Dance Academy — $865.00.

Amazon — $312.47.

Amazon — $189.99.

Nordstrom — $604.10.

Starlight Dance Academy — Competition Fee — $1,250.00.

By midnight, three pages of the statements were more yellow than white.

At the top of every page, in small gray print, it said: Westbrook Middle PTA — Sensory Room Fund.

My husband, Ben, came downstairs for a glass of water and found me there.

“Erin? What are you still doing up?”

I turned the stack around so he could see it.

He picked up the first page. He read it. Then he sat down slowly in the chair across from me.

“Who has the debit card for this account?” he asked.

I didn’t answer right away. I didn’t want to say it out loud, because once I said it, it would be real.

“Karen Sloane,” I said.

Ben looked up at me.

“Oh,” he said. “Oh, Erin.”

Upstairs, behind her bedroom door, our fourteen-year-old daughter was asleep with a cookbook open on her chest.

I didn’t know it yet, but in three weeks, those yellow pages and that cookbook were going to end up in the same room.


My daughter Lily has loved baking since she was six.

That was the year she discovered she could make something come out exactly right if she followed the steps. A quarter teaspoon was always a quarter teaspoon. Three hundred and fifty degrees was always three hundred and fifty degrees. If you creamed the butter and sugar for four minutes, not three, the cookies came out softer every single time.

The world doesn’t make that kind of sense very often. Especially not to Lily.

Lily is autistic. She was diagnosed when she was four, after a year of her preschool teachers telling us she was “just quiet” and “in her own world.” She didn’t talk much until she was almost five. She still doesn’t talk much with people she doesn’t know. Loud rooms hurt her ears. Bright lights give her headaches. When she’s overwhelmed, she rubs her thumb back and forth along the seam of her sleeve, over and over, until it calms her down. Most of her sweaters have a soft, worn spot on the left cuff.

But give her flour, butter, frosting, and a piping bag, and she can sit at our kitchen counter for hours working on the tiniest details. She once spent forty-five minutes piping the scales onto a single dragon cookie for her cousin’s birthday. Every scale was the same size. I measured.

So when the school announced in September that they were holding a Halloween Fair on the last Saturday of October, I was surprised at dinner when Lily put down her fork and said, “I want to do a bake sale table.”

Ben and I looked at each other.

“A table?” I said carefully. “By yourself?”

“Yes.”

“With people coming up to it? Talking to you? Asking questions?”

She was quiet for a moment. She rubbed her sleeve.

“Yes,” she said. “I’ve thought about it for four days. I can make a script.”

Lily makes scripts for hard things. Ordering at a restaurant. Answering the phone. Calling her grandmother. She writes them on index cards and practices them in the mirror.

“Ms. Delgado said the money from the fair goes to the new sensory room,” Lily said. “The one they’re building next to the library.”

Ms. Delgado is Lily’s special education teacher. Lily adores her.

“The calm corner in Ms. Delgado’s room only has one beanbag,” Lily went on. “And the light buzzes. If they build a real room, there will be dimmer switches. And weighted blankets. And a door that closes.”

She looked at her plate.

“I want to help pay for the door,” she said.

I had to get up and pretend I needed more water so she wouldn’t see my face.


Lily signed up the next morning. The registration form was due in the school office by October 10th. I watched her fill it out at the kitchen counter in her neat, careful print.

Student name: Lily Caldwell. Grade: 8. Table type: Bake Sale. Table name: Lily’s Spooky Bakery. Proceeds go to: Sensory Room Fund.

There was a fifteen-dollar table fee. She paid it out of her own savings. She has a jar on her dresser labeled MONEY in block letters, and she counted out a ten and five ones and put them in an envelope.

At the bottom of the form, there was a line for a parent signature. I signed it.

Above it, in smaller print, it said: Table assignments approved by Fair Committee Chair: Karen Sloane.

I looked at that name for a long time.


I need to tell you about Karen Sloane.

Karen has been the chair of the Westbrook PTA for three years. She’s tall, with expensive blonde highlights and a laugh you can hear across a parking lot. She drives a white Escalade with a sticker on the back window that says Dance Mom. She organizes everything: the fall carnival, the teacher appreciation luncheon, the spring auction. She runs the parent Facebook group, which has eleven hundred members, and she posts in it every day, usually with a lot of exclamation points.

Her daughter, Madison, is in Lily’s grade. Madison is bright, bubbly, and very pretty, and she competes in dance at a studio in town that costs, I would later learn, about as much each year as a used car.

Karen and I had never been friends. But I’d never had a real problem with her, either. Not until the sixth-grade orientation night two years ago.

The gym was packed and loud. Lily was wearing her noise-canceling headphones, the big gray ones, and holding my hand. A boy knocked into her, and she flinched hard and made a small sound, almost a squeak, and pressed her hands against the headphones.

Karen was standing right next to us with a clipboard.

She looked at Lily. Then she looked at me with a little sympathetic face, the kind of face you make at a dog with three legs.

“Oh, bless her,” she said. “Is she going to be in the regular classes? Or the… other ones?”

“She’s in regular classes,” I said. “With support.”

“Well, that’s so brave of you,” Karen said. And she patted my arm and walked away.

Lily didn’t hear it. The headphones were good ones.

But I did.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *